I need a little help. I have been doing taxes so far this year and most of my clients haven decided to take the self employed tax deferral on Sch SE-T. Fast forward, now they are calling me telling me that their refunds are less than what their return had said.
My question is, Why is this happening? The worksheet is kind of confusing but I thought it was an option for self employed clients to take this deferral. Am I missing something here?
I am pretty sure the IRS is denying them the deferral because I have gone back in and removed the amount on line 18 and it is showing the amount the IRS actually sent them.
My guess is you're trying to defer taxes that were already paid. You can reduce the amount due and defer payment to 12/31/21 and 12/31/22 but you can't increase a refund by taxes already paid.
From the 1040 instructions to Schedule 3 (2020 PDF page 100😞
"If you file Schedule H or Schedule SE, you can defer some of the household employment and self-employment tax payments you may owe on your 2020 tax return and pay them later instead. However, you can't defer amounts that you have already paid."
I am experiencing the same thing. This deferral is the EE portion of the Self Employment tax once the NET income is multiplied by 92.35%. The IRS stopped honoring this Covid provision, or their internal systems began disallowing this deferral (to be paid later) and the refunds are being reduced. This appears to be a screw up on the IRS's part, not our software or how the provision is written. I tried researching if this rule has expired but can't find anything. I asked ACS and PPS at the IRS and they haven't heard of this happening --- and, as far as they're concerned, it's still the taxpayer's option for SE. I'm sure there will be more to come.
Ideally the software should have caught this or at least gave some kind of diagnostic (or maybe it did and nobody read it?)...I haven't had anyone interested in deferring.
Ironically, this wasn't one of the things that the IRS had to cobble together in the middle of tax season. These provisions have been around for a year now, they could have come up with a better reporting system.
That said, nothing has changed since I posted in this thread on 3/3/21. You can't increase a refund with a deferral. You never could.
I'm with Lisa, I haven't had anyone do this either (I'm considering doing it for myself just 'cause I'm curious how the IRS is going to handle it). Anyone with a deferral amount that is less than their total refund shouldn't have bothered trying to defer.
There are conceptually some borderline cases where the only correct solution is to have the IRS hold the refund. Say I have a balance due of $1,500 which includes $2,000 of deferrable SE tax. I do the SE deferral paperwork and now my return shows a $500 refund. Somewhere in the IRS system will be data that show I owe $1,000 on 12/31/21 and $1,000 on 12/31/22. And then it will also show that my $500 refund was held and applied to the 12/31/21 balance due. This is the only way to get the full $1,000 deferred to 12/31/22.
What a mess.
This is Not what is happening: "The IRS stopped honoring this Covid provision, or their internal systems began disallowing this deferral (to be paid later) and the refunds are being reduced."
It's to provide parity to the Employers that can do this with FICA funds. And all of the provisions (employer or SE) include that it is Not Refundable. If you already paid more than this, they don't refund what you wanted to Defer.
Are you using IRS resources:
"30. Is a self-employed individual who defers 50 percent of the Social Security tax on net earnings from self-employment income, or a household employer that defers the employer's share of Social Security tax under section 2302 of the CARES Act, eligible for a refund of the deferred amount of tax at the time the taxpayer files its Form 1040, Individual Tax Return? (added July 30, 2020)
Generally, no. A taxpayer who has deferred his or her payment of the employer's share of Social Security tax or 50% of the Social Security tax on net earnings from self-employment under section 2302 of the CARES Act is not eligible for a refund due to the deferral because the deferral amount is a deferral of payment, not a deferral of liability. Therefore, the deferral itself does not result in an overpayment of taxes reported on Form 1040. However, if a household employer is eligible for advanceable paid leave credits under the FFCRA and reports those credits on Schedule H, Form 1040, the taxpayer may receive a refund of the paid leave credits even while deferring the employer's share of Social Security tax. This does not apply to credits for sick leave and family leave equivalent amounts for self-employed individuals.
Self-employed individuals and household employers should consider deferrals under section 2302 of the CARES Act in determining their estimated tax payments and any income tax withholding from wages and other sources of income. Publication 505, Tax Withholding and Estimated Tax for use in 2020 provides more details on determining these amounts."
"Level Up" is a gaming function, not a real life function.
I need help!
I had a lot of my customer called in about Section 2302 deferral for certain Schedule H or SE.
I fund out that number on form 1040 line 31==> from Schedule 3 line 12e ==> the Deferral from self-employer income should be negative for withhold. Why that number become positive for return?. It is some thing wrong from our software?
It's not a negative. It's an entire section that is adding together, so that the total or summed value can be used as needed in later steps. And it's not a withholding. A deferral of amount owed to be paid later is not withheld; it's being ignored for the time being.
"Level Up" is a gaming function, not a real life function.