Solved! Go to Solution.
"Brokerage house tells me it can be reported for 2021 since it was done in January."
Nope. You need to stop listening to Brokers, by the way. They are starting to seem like solar salesman: "Really, you will get a rebate, and a tax credit, and you will make so much money when you sell back that electricity, and all of your own electricity will be Free for the rest of your life; just sign here."
You want evidence it was tagged as a 2021 contribution. That's the only reason it is part of a 2021 tax return.
And any further event is a separate event that happened when it happened and gets reported as such. That conversion happened in 2022.
sounds like a debit and a credit therefore you do nothing
It sounds to me like even though it started out as a traditional IRA by converting it to a ROTH Ira it has most likely been handled by the powers that be as an Original Roth and since it does not effect your taxes untill it is withdrawn I dont think you have a problem.
so..... he possibly has a 2021 non-deductible IRA (depending on how they treated it), which creates a basis, but no way he '"back-doored" it in calendar year 2021. And even if they marked it originally a 2021 contribution, i would lean on the advisor to somehow make the contribution a 2022 contribution, then convert it. I think 2021 is a lost cause here.
Thanks for your quick responses. Brokerage house tells me it can be reported for 2021 since it was done in January. I believe you can still report this for 2021 tax year since it’s done before filing deadline, right?
The broker is wrong. That's why you can't figure out how to enter it into the software. While the contribution can be designated for TY 2021 or TY 2022, the conversion happens when it happens and is reported in that tax year. Sounds like in your case that's 2022.
If the traditional IRA contribution was designated as 2021 you will need to fill out an 8606 to report the non-deductible contribution and start tracking basis. Next year you'll get a 1099-R showing the conversion.
"Brokerage house tells me it can be reported for 2021 since it was done in January."
Nope. You need to stop listening to Brokers, by the way. They are starting to seem like solar salesman: "Really, you will get a rebate, and a tax credit, and you will make so much money when you sell back that electricity, and all of your own electricity will be Free for the rest of your life; just sign here."
You want evidence it was tagged as a 2021 contribution. That's the only reason it is part of a 2021 tax return.
And any further event is a separate event that happened when it happened and gets reported as such. That conversion happened in 2022.
Thank you - appreciate you and others for taking time out to respond to my Q.
You have clicked a link to a site outside of the ProConnect Community. By clicking "Continue", you will leave the Community and be taken to that site instead.