Thank you both for your replies.
I'm not sure the coding of the income is the issue.
The income was actually earned in NY.
It is only taxable in NC and VA as resident states.
As a full year resident of NC in previous years, the income was recognized and taxed and the credit for taxes paid to NY was calculated.

I also recently prepared a return for someone who moved from NY to SC and the income was allocated appropriately based on dates of residence, but the SC input/residency questions were different in the program than they are for NC and VA.