Sounds like the makings of another class-action lawsuit.  Have you tried contacting the lawyers that settled the first one?

Taxes were withheld?  Do you know how much?  

Maybe a Form 4852 as a substitute 1099-R.

Remember, J. P. Morgan made his money the old-fashioned way.  He cheated.  He bought defective rifles from the Union Army in the East, during the Civil War, and sold them at a profit to the Union Army in the West.  Not much has changed since those days.