mcd1231
Level 4

She rolled over her direct contributions from her Roth at work to a Roth IRA in 2018. 

The earnings from the Roth at work were rolled over to a traditional IRA. 

When she took the $5,500 withdrawal in 2018, she took it from her Roth contributions IRA not the traditional IRA. 

The 5 year rule applies to withdrawal of earnings from a Roth or a conversions from a traditional IRA to a Roth or an inherited Roth IRA. None of these situations apply to my client.

0 Cheers